SHOULD PUBLIC BE TOLD OF SERIAL KILLERS? Police and Citizen Interests Often Collide

Police and Citizen Interests Often Collide

By Kevin Heldman

NEW YORK ( — Are lives further endangered when local police withhold information about a possible serial killer — or when they release it?

This is one of the most contentious aspects of the relationship between communities and their police agencies during a serial killer investigation, according to veterans on all sides of the issue.

The debate has led to a number of conflicts:

In Milwaukee, Wis., at least 12 women have been strangled in
what may be the work of one person, but the police department refuses comment on any aspect of the case.

In Portland, Ore., a criminal investigator still refuses talk to
the local newspaper because 16 years ago the editor refused to run a composite of a suspected killer for fear the paper would be perceived as an arm of law enforcement.

In Kansas City, Mo., after nine women were killed and dumped in
the Missouri River, the brother-in-law of one of the victims started a web site to chronicle what is known about the possible serial killer cluster. Complaining that not enough information is being provided by law enforcement, he posted the victims’ photos and opened an e-mail forum to the community.

‘Cutthroat’ Media

Dr. Thomas Streed, a retired homicide detective from San Diego with extensive experience in investigating cold cases, points out problems on both sides, “The media is a cutthroat, competitive business so you get reporters, each of them trying to get an investigator to say something more sensational or provocative than what was said to the last reporter. What happens is that these detectives get very pissed off being the target of the competition between members of the media.”

On the law enforcement side Streed says he’s been involved in
investigations where police officials competed to put out the press release. “The brutal reality is that they don’t give a s**t
about the case being solved,” he said. “They’re more interested in
seeing themselves on television because that’s the fast track to recognition. It’s very, very helpful to your career and your prestige.”

The standard reason given by most law enforcement agencies as to why they refuse to release information is that they want to hold on to facts that only the killer would know. “If we have some guy come in and say he heard this guy talking in a bar that he shot some female six times in the head, and if I know that information wasn’t released in the media, that’s good information,” says Sgt. Dave Bernard, a Kansas City homicide detective.

Press as Enemy?

In some cases, however, law enforcement’s reluctance to provide
information seems less about preserving the integrity of an investigation than a reflex response — the press is the
enemy and law enforcement has an absolute proprietary right to

Mark Profit, who’s serving two consecutive life sentences for murder and attempted rape, is considered by Minneapolis police to be the person responsible for the murders of three other women. They’re so sure he did it that they feel it would be a waste of time and money to prepare a case against him and there is no active investigation being conducted.

However, in response to the question of why the police believe Profit committed these murders, Penny Parrish, Public Information Officer for the force, responds that the department never releases any information unless they’re pleading with the public for help.


“Because it would compromise the investigation.”


“It would ruin it.”

But there is no investigation.

And so on, until she terminated the conversation.

“Under most circumstances that little magical piece of information that the police want to hold back doesn’t exist,” Streed says. “You’ve got a decomposed body in a dump job, what is it that you’re going to hold back — the fact that the victim was laying on their right side? Guess what, most killers don’t even know how the body wound up when they pitched him out of a car…The fact is a lot of killers aren’t even certain how many times they fired the gun anyway, and they don’t know where those bullets went; they’re in panic state.”

Tremendous Amount of Pressure

Spokane County Sheriffs’ Department Captain Doug Silver, who’s leading a task force investigating a serial killer responsible for at least eight dead women, says that there’s a tremendous amount of pressure on a police force once a department goes public with the fact that they have a serial killer. He also says an agency can actually be hindered by the number of bad tips that come in when information is released. His agency has already received approximately 2,800 tips.

A police announcement that someone has been killed is enough of an alert to the public, says Dr. Robert Keppel, Chief Criminal Investigator for the Washington State Attorney General’s
Office, who’s been involved as a consultant or a reviewer in numerous serial murder investigations.

“As to the details of the murder itself, there’s nothing that’s going
to make the public any safer by releasing any of that stuff, but there’s a lot of political pressure  that comes on the departments [and] they end up having to say something because the mayor wants something said.”

Information Used by Killer

As for jeopardizing an investigation, Keppel points out that in the
Atlanta child murders in the early 1980s, right after the press reported that the killer was leaving hair and fibers on the
bodies, all subsequent bodies were dumped in the river.

John Douglas, former head of the FBI’s Behavioral Sciences Unit and a consultant to APB, believes law enforcement should use the media, specifically to release information that can help to protect the public (how the killer operates, for example), as well as information that will put pressure on the subject.

Douglas explained how, when working a case in Seattle, he released
descriptions of what the suspect’s pre- and post-offense behavior was probably like. A family read the article, thought (correctly, as it turned out) that it fit the behavior of their son and contacted the authorities.

Douglas says it’s likely the murderer will be following the press. “It
drives me crazy when I hear a chief of police say, ‘We’ve exhausted all leads.’ That creates a big sigh of relief on the part of an offender — they never, never should say that.” The flip side of this is that law enforcement sometimes puts out disinformation intended to influence the unknown suspect — a tactic that, even if done infrequently, contributes to the media’s skepticism about police information.
Douglas does say he was involved in one case where disinformation was put out — the media were told that the police had a description of an individual and his vehicle. As they hoped, the subject “injected” himself into the investigation and he was caught.

“The more eyeballs that are out there looking for somebody, then the quicker they get caught, but the police play this dumbass game of, ‘We can’t release that information,'” Streed said. “Just once I’d like to have a six month trial period where police are obligated to release every blessed thing that they know about a case to the news media. I’ll bet the closure and successful prosecution rate would go up.”

On the other side of the debate Keppel quotes Ted Bundy’s own warning about the release of information, “The police say far too much to the press.”

Kevin Heldman is an APB News staff writer


10 responses

  1. Just read the first part of your report on Manoku and other Albanian thugs. Very nice work, I should say, and I have a bit of experience on which to base that comment. I’ve spent more than 20 years on one Albanian-related story – reasons are or were valid for the multiple delays. My tale is ancient history and gets into a secret world of decades ago, but I was able to transit from Tosk to Gheg, from leftwing Ballist to Blokist (if you know the meaning of those terms). I got a bit into the drug smuggling with my first ever Albanian story (and worked a little with a guy named Dan Jannison, who once did some high level reporting in Albany). I must admit that I never did the deeply in-depth penetrations that you say you did, into all those coffeeshops and restaurants and bars in the Bronx, Dearborn, and Staten Island. Did you ever visit the Bektashi tekke in Taylor, MI? Like you, I am not Albanian, and actually found that to be somewhat beneficial except for the lingo difficulties. I have finally started writing whatever the product I turn out will be (book or article), but still find reasons to do the research I prefer tackling. Anyway, keep up the good work, and I will try to check in on you aNd see what’s new in the world of Albanians in America. Things are not totally as great as Americans prefer to think they are, I guess. An Albanian kid who just graduated from my town’s local high school gave as his goal for the future a return to Albania.


  2. We absolutely love your blog and find a lot of your post’s to be what precisely I’m looking for. Do you offer guest writers to write content available for you? I wouldn’t mind publishing a post or elaborating on a few of the subjects you write regarding here. Again, awesome weblog!


  3. Your article has confirmed necessary to us. It’s quite informative
    and you’re naturally really well-informed in this field. You get opened our face in order to numerous thoughts about this particular subject along with intriquing, notable and reliable written content.


  4. Have you ever considered about including a little bit more
    than just your articles? I mean, what you say is valuable and
    everything. But think of if you added some great visuals or videos to give your posts
    more, “pop”! Your content is excellent but with pics and clips, this site could certainly be one of the best in its niche.

    Awesome blog!


  5. Thanks for a really great post – to give back again a little, heres a estimate coming from my own top 100: 74. Flawlessness isn’t achievable, however in the event many of us pursue flawlessness we can catch excellence. — Vince Lombardi


  6. Hello There. I found your blog using msn. This is a really well written article. I’ll be sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your useful info. Thanks for the post. I’ll definitely return.


  7. Hi there, I find that your case is rather perceptive as it highlights a whole lot of accurate data. By the way, was thinking regardless of whether you’d adore to interchange world wide web links with my world wide web portal, as I am looking to produce contacts to additional spear issue and obtain ground for my world wide web space. I don’t mind you laying my world-wide-web links at the property page, just approving this links on this particular article is over enough. Furthermore, would you be type adequate contact me at my world wide web space if you are keen during the link exchange, I would extremely like that. Very best wishes from me and hope to hear from you shortly!


  8. Good day! I could have sworn I’ve been to this web site before but after looking at many of the posts I realized it’s new
    to me. Nonetheless, I’m definitely happy I found it and I’ll be bookmarking it and checking back frequently!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: